Short answer: shape changes the look, not the softness
An octabox and a rectangular softbox both soften light, and for the same size and distance they are about equally soft. The shape changes three things: the catchlight in the eyes, the pattern of light falloff across the subject, and how easily you can control the edges. If you’re buying one box for portraits, pick the shape that matches the catchlight and framing you want.
Catchlights: round vs window-like
The catchlight is the reflection of the light in the subject’s eyes. The shape of the light source shows up in that reflection.
- Octabox. Gives a round or circular catchlight that looks like the sun or a natural reflection.
- Rectangular softbox. Gives a square or rectangular catchlight, which looks like a window or studio reflection.
Neither is wrong. Round catchlights read as natural in most portraits, while a rectangle gives a distinct window look.
Light falloff and control
The shapes spread light differently across the subject:
- Rectangular softbox. Straight edges give a clearer, more controllable edge. It’s easy to feather, which means aiming the edge of the light past the subject. It also controls spill well, especially with a grid. It can be turned vertically for full-length portraits or horizontally for groups and reclining subjects.
- Octabox. The multi-sided shape gives a rounder, wrap-around light with a less obvious edge. Because it is nearly symmetrical, it has a fixed orientation and can’t be turned the way a rectangle can.
Shape changes the look of the edge, not how soft the light is for the same source size. Softness depends on source size relative to the subject and distance.
Feathering and flags
Rectangular edges are easier to shape precisely with flags. If you need a clean edge on a product or a sharp shadow line, a rectangle is usually easier to control. An octabox is easier when you want a smooth wrap and don’t need to fine-tune the edge.
Best uses by shape
Octabox
Octaboxes suit:
- Single-person portraits and headshots
- Beauty work where a round catchlight and flattering wrap help
- Outdoor or natural-looking key light
- Classic portrait key lights
Rectangular softbox and strip box
Rectangular softboxes suit:
- Full-length portraits, using the box vertically
- Groups, using the box horizontally
- Tight studio spaces near walls or ceilings
- Product photography, where clean rectangular highlights help
Strip boxes, which are narrow rectangles around 12 by 36 to 12 by 56 inches, are mainly used for rim, hair and edge light.
Sizes and construction
Octaboxes commonly come in 36 to 60 inches (90 to 150 cm), and deep or parabolic octas can reach around 7 ft. Rectangles often come as 24 by 36 inches (60 by 90 cm) or 36 by 48 inches (90 by 120 cm), with square boxes at 24 or 32 inches.
Octabox size may be measured corner-to-corner or flat-to-flat, depending on the brand. Compare sizes using the same measurement method.
Both shapes usually have an inner baffle, a front diffuser and a recessed front, and both can take optional grids. Deep octas are more directional and accept grids better than shallow ones.
Prices are similar at the same size. Large octas usually cost more than smaller ones.
Common misconceptions
- An octabox is not inherently softer than a rectangle. At the same area, they are close.
- An octabox is not an umbrella. It has much less spill.
- You need both shapes to start. One box of about 90 cm covers most portraits, in either shape.
Which one to buy first
If you shoot mostly headshots and portraits, buy a medium octabox, roughly 90 cm (36 inches). If you shoot full-length portraits, groups or products, a rectangular softbox is usually more useful. Strip boxes are an add-on, not a first buy.
Our softbox size guide helps match the box size to your framing. For a comparison with a beauty dish, see beauty dish vs softbox.
Safety
Large octas catch wind and put leverage on stands. Sandbag them, or use a C-stand.