Flash Photography

TTL vs Manual Flash: Which Mode to Use and When

TTL flash sets power automatically from a pre-flash; manual gives fixed, repeatable output. Learn how each works, when to use it, and how compensation helps.

On this page
  1. How TTL works
  2. How manual works
  3. Distance and the inverse square law
  4. Flash exposure compensation
  5. Off-camera and hybrid use
  6. When to use TTL
  7. When to use manual
  8. A simple workflow
  9. Common misconceptions

TTL and manual are the two main ways to set flash output. In TTL, the camera works out the power for each shot from a short pre-flash. In manual, you choose the output yourself, and the flash fires at that setting every time. Neither is better in every case. The right mode depends on whether the scene changes quickly and whether you need the same result from shot to shot.

How TTL works

TTL stands for through the lens. When you press the shutter, the flash fires a brief pre-flash a few milliseconds before the main burst. The camera meters the light that comes back through the lens and sets the power of the main flash from that reading.

Camera makers use different names for their TTL systems. Canon uses E-TTL II, Nikon uses i-TTL, Sony uses ADI, Pentax uses P-TTL, and Fujifilm and OM System also offer TTL. The names describe similar ideas, so check the manual for your system.

TTL meters the scene, not the flash itself. That means the flash output depends on the subject, the background, and how reflective the surfaces are. A dark or bright background can change the result.

The pre-flash can cause a small problem for a subject who blinks. If they close their eyes just as the pre-flash fires, they may still have their eyes closed for the main burst.

How manual works

In manual mode, the flash output is a fixed fraction of full power. The scale runs from 1/1 down to 1/128, and some units go as low as 1/256. Each step halves the output, which is one stop.

Manual output is repeatable when the flash-to-subject distance and the power setting stay the same. That makes it useful for studio work, for lighting several subjects the same way, and for matching a look across many shots.

Many photographers start at a middle setting, such as 1/8 or 1/16, take a test shot, and adjust from there.

Distance and the inverse square law

Flash light falls off with the square of distance, so moving the subject from 2 m to 4 m cuts the light to a quarter. In manual mode, you need two stops more power to make up the difference. In TTL, the camera does this for you, as long as the subject stays in the metering area.

Flash exposure compensation

Flash exposure compensation (FEC) lets you adjust TTL output up or down without changing to manual. Most systems offer a range of about plus or minus three stops, in steps of a third of a stop. FEC changes the flash only. It doesn’t change the ambient exposure, which you control with shutter speed, aperture and ISO.

FEC is useful for fill flash outdoors. A common starting point is one to two stops below the ambient exposure, which lifts the shadows on the subject without making the flash look obvious. The balance of flash and daylight is covered in balancing flash and ambient light.

Many cameras and flashes also have FE lock. This sets the flash output from one reading, so you can recompose the frame without the flash power changing. Canon calls it FE lock, often on a dedicated button, and Nikon uses flash value (FV) lock.

Off-camera and hybrid use

TTL works off-camera with compatible triggers, but the flash position matters. If the flash sits in a much brighter or darker area than the subject, the camera may read the wrong exposure.

Some flashes can switch a TTL reading to manual power, which gives you a consistent setting after the first test. Check your model’s manual for this option.

Groups can mix modes. For example, you can run a TTL key light with a manual rim light. See multiple off-camera flash techniques for group and channel setup.

When to use TTL

TTL suits situations where the light changes quickly:

  • Events, receptions, and moving subjects
  • Changing distances, such as walking around a room
  • Run-and-gun work, where you need to move fast

When to use manual

Manual suits controlled work:

Both modes work with high-speed sync on compatible flashes. For the trade-offs of HSS, see high-speed flash photography.

A simple workflow

  1. Choose the mode based on the job. TTL for fast, changing scenes; manual for controlled ones.
  2. Take a test shot in TTL and check the exposure on the subject.
  3. If the results vary too much from shot to shot, switch to manual and set the power.
  4. In TTL, adjust with FEC. In manual, change the power or the distance.

Common misconceptions

  • Manual is not only for professionals. Beginners can use it for controlled portraits, and many professionals use TTL for fast events.
  • Manual flash doesn’t require manual camera mode. You can use manual flash with the camera in aperture priority or other modes, and the reverse also works.
  • Optical slaves with a TTL master can fire early. The pre-flash can trigger them before the main flash. Set the slave to the mode that ignores the pre-flash, often labeled S2. See multiple off-camera flash techniques.

The complete guide to flash photography

Flash Photography for Beginners: A Complete Tutorial
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →